Skip to Content

Fudgy Butterfinger Cookies

These fudgy Butterfinger cookies are a special treat for the holidays. They’re loaded with Butterfinger candy bars and peanut butter chips for an extra bit of sweetness!

Last night was my first ever holiday party. I didn’t take the time this summer to throw my normal pool party so I figured why not cram everyone into our house with not nearly enough chairs or space and just make things awkward for everyone. Cozy right?

holiday party table

The guests were a mix of my customers, friends, family, co-workers, ex-coworkers and a random dude who was rooting for the wrong team based on his baseball cap. It was the widest group of dietary needs I have ever had to keep in mind as well but I think I succeeded in having a little something for everyone.

holiday party foods

The spread:

Smoked Pulled Pork

smoked pork, before the pulling

Fudgy Butterfinger Cookies \\ Recipe on

These Butterfinger cookies are super yummy and remind me a lot of a cookie my dad makes every year at the holidays. You will quickly find yourself  munching on more then you planned to (especially when they are fresh from the oven) and you may have trouble saving some for Santa.


Update: This fudgy Butterfinger cookies post made it to FoodBuzz Top 9!

Jenny @ melting butter

Wednesday 22nd of December 2010

wow, very impressive! :)


Tuesday 21st of December 2010

Mmm...I love Butterfingers. I haven't had them in quite some time, though. Now would be the perfect excuse to get those sticky bits stuck in between my teeth. :-p


Tuesday 21st of December 2010

Cute, cute, cute! I love the polka dot plates! ;)


Monday 20th of December 2010

Looks like a wonderful spread. :) The good.


Monday 20th of December 2010

Looks like you were busy cooking! The list of food looks awesome! Hope it was fun!