Peanut butter Oreo popsicles are going to become your new favorite frozen treat. Trust me on this!
I'm sure I have burnt you out on popsicle recipes this summer, but pity me for I am ice cream maker-less. Not that I can really complain, because I don't have a vast amount of space in the freezer for one anyway. But the chimes have rung out in my mind and I am scurrying to get up all the summer fun posts I have been squirreling away before the leaves change color.
It was like a silent alarm went off in my head this weekend as I started contemplating holiday gifts. There are no birthdays or real celebrations from mid-September until December in our family. Everyone is either a product of cold winters or has their birthday stifled by other family holidays. Which means that from August 17th on, it's full on holiday shopping mode for me.
No, I wont be the person picking out my holiday ornaments before I hand out the last of last year's candy to the kids at Halloween. But I can start to plot. To stir up my ideas of grandeur, the most awesomest of awesome gifts, the tastiest party, the stocking stuffers and so on. I am like a freakin ninja squirrel of holiday presents, stocking up and storing for that special day. Sure, there are apples to be picked, pumpkins to be haunted, and turkeys to be carved, but from here on out, somewhere in the back of my head, the Christmas bells are ringing.
I hope that song is just as stuck in your head as it is mine right now.
There's no undoing that one. Sorry. But at least it has you thinking of cold things, like popsicles!
Peanut butter Oreo popsicles, if you please.
📖 Recipe
Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles
Ingredients
- 1 container whipped cream - not the kind in the squirty jar, thawed
- 8 ounces cream cheese - softened
- 18 Peanut Butter Oreo cookies - plus 4
Instructions
- In a ziplock bag, whack the cookies around a bit so that they are broken into large chunks. I like to use a rolling pin and let out some frustrations. Don’t go haywire though, you don’t want crumbs, yet.
- In another bag with remaining Oreo’s, beat the living day lights out of things for a fine cookie crumbly topping.
- In a large bowl, whip cream cheese until light and fluffy. Fold in the whipped cream and cookie chunks.
- Pour mixture into popsicle molds or wax lined disposable cups. Gently pat down to make sure all air bubbles are filled in. Insert your wooded craft sticks and sprinkle cookie crumbs on top, pressing gently with your fingers.
- Freeze for at least 4 hours.
- Remove pops from molds and enjoy.
- To make this dessert “healthy”, you could use light whipped cream and low fat cream cheese.
Nutritional informations provided as a courtesy and is only an approximatation. Values will changes based on ingredients used.
⭐ Tried this recipe? Rate it ⭐
Help out the next person and give it a star rating below!
To be fair, Handsome's b-day is around the holidays. And so are several other awesome peoples, so it's not all Christmas planning.
If you are not a fan of the holidays, don't worry. Pass the Sushi will remain seasonal and fat kid friendly long before it becomes like the shelves of your local art store after the 4th of July.
Belinda @zomppa says
Holiday gifts? Say it ain't so! These popsicles are reasons to celebrate any day.
Maggie @ Vittles and Bits says
Oh you had me laughing with this post... 'ninja squirrel of holiday presents.' Love it ... AND these popsicles, yummy! Be lucky you don't have an ice cream maker, they are dangerous 😛
Curt says
Great idea. i love the peanut butter Oreo cookies. I especially like the whacking and beating up cookies part.
I'll bet they taste great!
Katrina @ In Katrina's Kitchen says
I just died.
Kaitlin says
Oh my. I have never wanted a popsicle as much as I want one of these. Amazing!
Parsley Sage says
Whoa. These are outstanding. My inner fat kid just knocked down my inner health nut and skinned her knees to smoosh his face against the screen. Well done and totally buzzed.
Speaking of Halloween...any ideas? We went as Paul Bunyan & Babe last year.
Nicole @ Bake Me Blush says
Those look delish-- excellent idea. Don't worry, you're not alone-- I too am ice cream maker-less!
Erin says
Oh my word I am in love with these. But I cannot find peanut butter oreos anywhere! It's heart-breaking. Why are fun food items so difficult to hunt down where I live??
Michelle O says
Oh wow... these look SOOOOO good. I popcicle that uses cream cheese. Brilliant. Reminds me of those jello pudding pops I miss and love. Saving this one. Buzzed! 🙂
Tina@flourtrader says
I have never seen peanut butter oreos, obviously I am missing out. These popsicles look awesome and with so little ingredients-well done!
Stephanie says
These look so awesome!! Never seen someone use cream cheese in a popsicle, but I have no doubt they are delicious!
RavieNomNoms says
These are so much fun Kita!! I am loving this. I could never get tired of popsicles so bring'em on lady! 🙂
Yuri says
Those look good, Kita! I didn't know about PB oreo cookies. I don't think they sell them here... this recipe sounds so fun that I'm gonna try adding some oreo cookies to my next batch of popsicles 🙂
Erin @ Dinners, Dishes and Desserts says
Holy Crap Woman!! These are like pure heaven!
Tes says
What a cute and fun idea! I'm gonna put this to work right away 🙂
Kimber says
Yum!! These look absolutely delicious - especially for those warm summer nights!
claire @ the realistic nutritionist says
these pictures are gorgeous and they look SO good!!
Kelly says
Kita these look fantastic, oreos are my faaavorite!! Fabulous pictures too! 🙂
Carolyn says
I've been loviing all your popsicles. Such great flavours, this one included!
Joy says
I'm in love with this recipe.
Kate@Diethood.com says
OH WOW! I'm speechless! My daughter is going to want for you to adopt her after she sees this!!
Jill @ Dulce Dough says
These look so good! I didn't even realize there was such a thing as PB Oreos!
Lauren at Keep It Sweet says
Love all your popsicles but these are my favorite!!
Cassie @ Bake Your Day says
Great idea, once again, Kita! I love adding Oreos to my ice cream so I'm sure these would quickly become a favorite too!
Peggy says
I literally just had to cover my computer screen. The fiance is going to bug me all night now until I make these. Thanks Kita lol
I'm sure I'll be indulging in them soon enough!
baobabs says
so sinfully yum!!
Fresh and Foodie says
Haha! Dang! These are so amazing. Cookies and Cream ice cream is one of my favs, so these popsicles are really singin' my tune.
Ann says
Okay...where should I start? I know...how 'bout.....YUM! They look amazing and peanut butter and oreos is a brilliant combination! I love the pictures and the milk bottle. I also have to say - your recipe reads like a conversation with a friend....just lovely! Buzzed this with high hopes for Top9!
The Chocolate Priestess says
Interesting recipe, again more cream cheese, and an amazing photo.
Chrissy says
How FUN!! These look so cool!
Sandi says
Woooww!
I love when leftovers recycle into something wonderful like this!
Hester @ Alchemy in the Kitchen says
Well thanks for planting that brainworm - Christmas bells are ringing - gaaaaah! 🙂
Lovely creamy popsicles!
Mike @ How To Make A Smoothie At Home says
Wow!! An amazing looking dish. I can't wait to make it!!
ping says
Congrats on getting Top9!! They're gorgeous! Love the black and whiteness of it without actually being a B&W photo!
Clare @ Mrs Multitasker says
What a great idea! They look easy enough and so pretty too!
Evan @swEEts says
I'd like to be munching on one of these right about now and its only 10am!
sonia says
Hey, this is looking super cool, lovely idea and a great snack to munch anytime. Horray for popsicles and you too.....!!!
Luciana says
Amazing! Congrats on Top 9!
Sandra says
You crack me up Kita, Congratulations on Top 9!
Kate @ Kate from Scratch says
What a wonderful idea! My boys would love this. Seriously, a recipe like this is instant omnipotent power in our household. They'd do almost anything for such a perfect treat. Well done. Grats!
nipponnin says
This is so fun! Congratulations on top 9
Sommer@ASpicyPerspective says
Oh girl, this looks like it could be my undoing!
Jamie @ the unseasoned wok says
Kita so beautiful!! Handsome was happy I bet!! haha. BTW I liked your post over at Diethood today. You did great achieving the Kate look!
Jill says
I made these to entertain ourselves while we were waiting out Irene in NYC this weekend. They were amazing! I used fat free Cool Whip and 1/3 fat cream cheese and regular Oreos (I wish I could have found PB ones!) and it was still delicious. Just like cookies and cream cheesecake!
Tamar says
Peanut butter? Yep. Chocolate? Yep. Cream? Yep! Yummy? Yep! 🙂
Laney says
Hi Kita, I first saw your food picture on FoodBuzz and was immediately drawn to the black and white composition of the photo. After seeing your recipe, I have to say I am truly impressed! These are the most elegant popsicles I have ever seen, reminds me of Coco Chanel! It is such an original recipe and perfect for the (end of) summer. Thank you for sharing!
Patty H. says
I love this post...it made me laugh! These popsicles look awesome, thanks for sharing!
mallory says
how many popsicles does this recipe yield?
meatballs & milkshakes says
yum! I'm craving cookies and cream ice cream this weekend, these look amazing!
Chung-Ah | Damn Delicious says
Omg are you kidding me? These are to die for! And best of all, I just got a popsicle mold today!
Emily says
How much exactly is one container? And the recipe looks amazing! Thank you 😀
Karen says
I'm really confused by the "1 container whipped cream (not the kind in the squirty jar), thawed" ingredient. Do you mean frozen whipped topping, like cool whip? I assume this is what you mean, because whipping cream isn't usually sold frozen. But I have never heard whipped topping / Cool Whip referred to as whipped cream.
Kita says
Yep, cool whip is what I was meaning on that one. Whew, I need to go back and re-read this recipe ;D It's been a while.
Torry Conan says
Can I whip up some heavy whipping cream? I don't have any cold whip.
Kita says
I would certainly give it a go. i think CoolWhip tends to be a lot lighter than traditional whipped cream, which makes for a less dense pop - but I think with enough air in your whipped cream, these could be killer with the real thing!