Skip to Content

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles

Peanut butter Oreo popsicles are going to become your new favorite frozen treat. Trust me on this!

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles - Just 3 ingredients needed to make this sweet frozen treat! //

I’m sure I have burnt you out on popsicle recipes this summer, but pity me for I am ice cream maker-less. Not that I can really complain, because I don’t have a vast amount of space in the freezer for one anyway. But the chimes have rung out in my mind and I am scurrying to get up all the summer fun posts I have been squirreling away before the leaves change color.

It was like a silent alarm went off in my head this weekend as I started contemplating holiday gifts. There are no birthdays or real celebrations from mid-September until December in our family. Everyone is either a product of cold winters or has their birthday stifled by other family holidays. Which means that from August 17th on, it’s full on holiday shopping mode for me.

No, I wont be the person picking out my holiday ornaments before I hand out the last of last year’s candy to the kids at Halloween. But I can start to plot. To stir up my ideas of grandeur, the most awesomest of awesome gifts, the tastiest party, the stocking stuffers and so on. I am like a freakin ninja squirrel of holiday presents, stocking up and storing for that special day. Sure, there are apples to be picked, pumpkins to be haunted, and turkeys to be carved, but from here on out, somewhere in the back of my head, the Christmas bells are ringing.

I hope that song is just as stuck in your head as it is mine right now.

Selected for you :   Zesty Easy Lemon Pie Recipe

There’s no undoing that one. Sorry. But at least it has you thinking of cold things, like popsicles!

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles - Just 3 ingredients needed to make this sweet frozen treat! //

Peanut butter Oreo popsicles, if you please.

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles

Inspired by some leftovers I had laying about...


  • 1 container whipped cream, not the kind in the squirty jar, thawed
  • 8 ounces cream cheese, softened
  • 18 Peanut Butter Oreo cookies, plus 4


  1. In a ziplock bag, whack the cookies around a bit so that they are broken into large chunks. I like to use a rolling pin and let out some frustrations. Don’t go haywire though, you don’t want crumbs, yet.
  2. In another bag with remaining Oreo’s, beat the living day lights out of things for a fine cookie crumbly topping.
  3. In a large bowl, whip cream cheese until light and fluffy. Fold in the whipped cream and cookie chunks.
  4. Pour mixture into popsicle molds or wax lined disposable cups. Gently pat down to make sure all air bubbles are filled in. Insert your wooded craft sticks and sprinkle cookie crumbs on top, pressing gently with your fingers.
  5. Freeze for at least 4 hours.
  6. Remove pops from molds and enjoy.
  7. To make this dessert “healthy”, you could use light whipped cream and low fat cream cheese.

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles - Just 3 ingredients needed to make this sweet frozen treat! //

 To be fair, Handsome’s b-day is around the holidays. And so are several other awesome peoples, so it’s not all Christmas planning.

If you are not a fan of the holidays, don’t worry. Pass the Sushi will remain seasonal and fat kid friendly long before it becomes like the shelves of your local art store after the 4th of July.

Selected for you :   100 Grand Cupcakes - Now get off your cell phone.

Peanut Butter Oreo Popsicles - Just 3 ingredients needed to make this sweet frozen treat! //

Torry Conan

Wednesday 17th of August 2016

Can I whip up some heavy whipping cream? I don't have any cold whip.


Thursday 18th of August 2016

I would certainly give it a go. i think CoolWhip tends to be a lot lighter than traditional whipped cream, which makes for a less dense pop - but I think with enough air in your whipped cream, these could be killer with the real thing!


Sunday 31st of July 2016

I'm really confused by the "1 container whipped cream (not the kind in the squirty jar), thawed" ingredient. Do you mean frozen whipped topping, like cool whip? I assume this is what you mean, because whipping cream isn't usually sold frozen. But I have never heard whipped topping / Cool Whip referred to as whipped cream.


Monday 1st of August 2016

Yep, cool whip is what I was meaning on that one. Whew, I need to go back and re-read this recipe ;D It's been a while.


Thursday 20th of June 2013

How much exactly is one container? And the recipe looks amazing! Thank you :D

Chung-Ah | Damn Delicious

Friday 1st of June 2012

Omg are you kidding me? These are to die for! And best of all, I just got a popsicle mold today!

meatballs & milkshakes

Friday 25th of May 2012

yum! I'm craving cookies and cream ice cream this weekend, these look amazing!

Skip to Recipe