Skip to Content

Pilgrim Sandwich {Thanksgiving Leftovers Recipes}

Pilgrim sandwich: A compilation of Thanksgiving leftovers, tucked inside of a hearty roll. It’s the perfect day-after-Thanksgiving lunch!

Pilgrim sandwich | Kita Roberts

The best part about Thanksgiving? The leftovers, duh!
For as long as I can remember, a local sub shop has offered a sandwich all year round that is a carb-oholic’s dream come true. The sandwich starts with a beautiful thick hoagie roll overflowing with stuffing, turkey, cranberries and a slather of mayo. It’s the kind of sandwich that requires a long nap or a marathon immediately afterwards.  The kind of sandwich I only allow myself to order maybe once a year. It’s the kind of sandwich that give’s angels wings.

A Pilgrim Sandwich.

Oh yeah, it’s that good.

So, you can imagine how elated I am to stock up on ziplock containers and bring the mountains of Thanksgiving leftovers home and sink my teeth into one of these bad boys.

Pilgrim sandwich | Kita Roberts

If you’ve tried this Pilgrim Sandwich recipe or any other recipe on please don’t forget to rate the recipe and let me know where you found it in the comments below. I love hearing from you! You can also follow along for more good eats and travel tips on Instagram @passthesushi & @girlcarnivoreTwitter Facebook.

Pilgrim Sandwich

Pilgrim Sandwich

From Rachel Ray Magazine October 2011

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 4 minutes
Total Time 14 minutes


  • 3 store bought corn muffins, crumbled or diced
  • 1 tbsp extra-virgin olive oil
  • 3 tbsp butter
  • 1 apple chopped, mcintosh, honey crisp or gala
  • 1 small onion, finely chopped
  • 2 ribs celery from the heart with leafy tops, chopped
  • Salt and Pepper
  • Small handful flat-leaf parsley, finely chopped
  • 2 tsp poultry seasoning
  • few springs of thyme, finely chopped
  • 1-1 1/2 cups chicken stock
  • 1 cup whole-berry cranberry sauce
  • 1/2 cup vegan or regular mayo
  • 4 crusty hoagie or ciabatta rolls, split
  • 1 1/2 lbs fresh thick sliced roast turkey
  • 1 lb sliced sharp white cheddar cheese
  • Thinly sliced red onion and sliced cornichons for topping
Selected for you :   Spring Grilling: King Salmon with Peas and Mint


  1. Position a rack in the middle of the oven and preheat the broiler. 
  2. Brown the corn muffin pieces on a baking sheet, tossing once, for about 5 minutes.
  3. In a large skillet, heat the olive oil, 1 turn of the pan, over medium-high heat; melt in the butter. 
  4. Add the apple, onion, and celery; season with salt and pepper. Cook until crisp-tender, about 5 minutes. 
  5. Add the muffin pieces, parsley, poultry seasoning and thyme. Moisten with the chicken stock to your liking, 1 to 1 1/2 cups. Turn off the heat.
  6. Mix the cranberry sauce with the mayo and slather it on roll tops. 
  7. Assemble the sandwiches on the roll bottoms with cornbread stuffing, sliced turkey and cheese. 
  8. Broil to melt the cheese. 
  9. Top with the onion, cornichons and roll tops.

Pilgrim sandwich | Kita Roberts

In case you’re wondering, I say skip the above steps and use up that fridge full of leftovers!

Pumpkin Pie Cocoa -
Give Thanks Recipe: Pumpkin Pie Cocoa
Cheese Steak from Ioannoni's Bullroasters, in New Castle, Delaware
The Great Cheese Steak Debate 2011 - Ioannoni's VS Silview's

Skip to Recipe